Perhaps in celebration of the one year anniversary of us sending them the album, Matt Shimmer at Indieville.com has posted a review of Ok Fine. It's, like many of our reviews have been, mixed:
This interesting keyboard-infused pop album comes encased in a glossy origami-folded package (don't unwrap it, or you will fucking regret it!!), the most overt indication of Pants Pants Pants' quirky, electronic-heavy style. Their second album so far, this twelve-song collection endears its audience by way of (usually) cute female vocals and silly song structures. The latter characteristic, however, also causes Ok, Fine to fall flat on occasion. While catchy "Dino Love" and silly "Stay in School (Don't Play The Fool)" (dig the Horatio Sanz reference) are among the record's best, others (bizarre "Human Machines," too-long "You Have Died of Dysentery" [a reference to ancient educational computer game Oregon Trail]) drag down the fun due to weak melodies and mediocre overall sounds. Others, like Bettie Serveert-esque "Moonpretty" and experimental and compelling "Graphite" are almost really good, but fall just short of being completely realized. I'm not sure how often I will be pulling this disc out, though as far as goofy female-led pop music goes, this does the trick. A notable cover of Pearl Jam's "Jeremy" is included for good measure, replacing the PJ sound with a lighter pop vibe.
They also included this little fun fact:
Like Modest Mouse (which this band doesn't resemble in the least), Pants Pants Pants' first songs were recorded on answering machines.
Actually, our first song was written using messages left on our answering machine, not recorded on answering machines. I think this is a great illustration of the difference between the two bands. I couldn't sum it up any better myself.
It always strikes me how different everyone's take is on this album, and on our band in general. Much of this, I'm sure, has to do with our varying style. But I'm most stricken by how differently people hear our music than I do.
For example, I've always considered Human Machines to be one of our most straight ahead pop songs, but this reviewer considers it "bizarre." I've also always assumed that fans of Dino Love would like Human Machines as well. I lump them together, but obviously Matt Shimmer does not.
I've also never thought of our Jeremy cover as having a "lighter pop vibe."
I thank Matt for his faint praise of Graphite ("almost really good"). You see, one thing you might not know about my other two band-mates is that they are total Graphite haters. This is despite the fact that numerous individuals of impeccable taste has expressed their enjoyment of the song (including Lauren Lauren's very own MOTHER!). Maybe Matt's words will help to sway them back over to the side of good. Come on you two, it's "experimental and compelling," we just need to completely realize that fact.
High points of the review for me include the Bettie Serveert reference, "(usually) cute female vocals," "almost really good," and of course the affirmation that we in no way resemble Modest Mouse.
In the end, we're left with a wonderfully cherry-pickable review. Look for out of context quotes from this review in our press pack soon.
I'm encouraged that every reviewer seems to be able to find something they enjoy in our album, even if it's just the album art (thanks a lot East Bay Express). When we start releasing our ep's by genre (more on this later), I think those who find themselves in Matt's boat can procure a piece of work more to their liking.
Frankly, though, I think some of these reviewers could stand to take a lesson from this review. Now THAT'S how you review Ok Fine!











